V 2, :(
From Facism to Terrorism
The biggest change in the plot of the story shown in the pilot episode is that the tactics for invasion have shifted from facist domination to terrorism. I find that both interesting and strange. It is clear from the dialogue that the "visitors" are rumored to have already infiltrated key social systems (e.g. government) in such a way that I find it suspect that they would resort to terrorism. Terrorism is often adopted by people who have little to no access to more powerful channels of persuasion or force, which is not the case with the "visitors". Thus, this plot line, while more relevant to today, already has me wondering if this is a mistake.
Not Like the Book (or Mini-series)
The very quick pace of the pilot left me with a feeling I think people feel when they read a book and are disappointed with the movie, as very rich parts of a story are cut out. Funny that I feel this moving from one version of a filmed narrative to a different version. What was so great about the story from the original mini-series was that we got into a lot of different lives who were impacted in very complex social ways by the tactics used from the antagonists. In the recent series pilot episode, everything is so compact, I really don't give a rat's ass how any of the character's lives are going right now.
Dynamic but Without Mystery
I certainly agree that this story moved through some of the same elements of the original story with a "let's not waste time with the obvious" attitude. However, a good storyteller knows how to reshape a story, to preserve the driving forces that are common to all good stories while still preventing boring rehashes of old plot points. The characters were used in the pilot to reveal the dynamics of the circumstances, leaving them poorly defined in and of themselves and without personality. There's no mystery to me nor even a character that I can say I want to get to know better.
Lowering Expectations but Persistent Hopes
There are three more episodes to help build up the story, and I certainly hope they rescue this story that is crashing like a jet knocked down by an overpowering alien ship. I remember feeling a similar weirdness with the first episode of Battlestar Galactica, which was ultimately a very impressive story to me. As such, I am crossing my fingers. However, they better learn how to make the characters worth watching and the mysteries worth Twittering about, or the show will most likely die shortly after the fourth episode finished airing.
